TP33: Better late than never? The policy and politics of expansionary ECEC reforms in latecomer contexts

  • Stefania Sabatinelli, Politecnico di Milano, Department of Architecture and Urban Studies
  • Shu-Yung, Brenda, Wang, Department of Social welfare, National Chung-Cheng University

Timing issues have been crucial in the development and expansion of early childhood education and care (ECEC) systems, with post-industrial conditions of permanent austerity making the endeavour more difficult for latecomer countries. The labour-intensive character of ECEC services generates a well-known trilemma between coverage expansion, high quality, and financial sustainability for users, providers and funding bodies. The current context of polycrisis exacerbates both the need to expand ECEC and the difficulties of doing so.

Socio-demographic changes are reducing families’ care capacity and challenging established care arrangements worldwide. Familialistic countries, such as those in Southern Europe and East Asia, are particularly affected, as informal family care has traditionally played a comparatively greater role, implicitly reinforced by public policies through lower levels of formal provision and public support.

In many latecomer countries, such as Japan, South Korea and Taiwan in East Asia and Spain and Italy in Southern Europe, ECEC expansion has happened within mixed public–private systems, where increasing public investment has coexisted with continued reliance on private providers. This raises questions about the changing roles of the state, market and families in financing, providing and governing ECEC services.

Furthermore, the increasing care unaffordability reinforces access inequalities, excluding many children from the right to early education and socialization, and may sharpen the trade-off between childrearing and labour-market participation – pressing concerns in contexts with declining birth rates, comparatively low female employment and/or high educational poverty. Meanwhile, poor working conditions in the sector contribute to staff shortages.

Against this complex backdrop, attempts to reform ECEC systems, expand provision, enhance quality and/or increase affordability have been observed in some latecomer countries around the world. Non-exhaustive examples include Italy’s post-pandemic, EU-funded expansion plan; New York City’s affordability plan; and the emphasis on ECEC in China’s 15th Five-Year Plan.

Such initiatives are not uniform, either in terms of policy, namely the objectives pursued and the tools and organisational arrangements adopted, including different configurations of public-private provision, or of politics, that is coalitional dynamics and legitimation strategies and discourses.

The panel welcomes contributions that examine, both theoretically and empirically, the policy and politics of recent reforms or programmes that – across different latecomer contexts worldwide – aim at making ECEC provision more accessible, affordable and/or inclusive. Papers addressing public-private provision, market governance and the redistribution of care responsibilities are particularly welcome. Proposals may examine a single case or take a comparative approach and may adopt a single- or a multi-level perspective.

Posted in Thematic Panels.