- Jarell Yung-Ching Chang
PhD Candidate, Department of Comparative Literature and Literary Theory, The University of Pennsylvania (UPenn)
Predoctoral Fellow, Institute of European and American Studies, Academia Sinica, Taiwan
Since the 1980s, feminist care ethicists in the wake of Carol Gilligan have appealed to the shared human conditions of vulnerability, interdependence, and connectedness, as a corrective to masculinist ideologies of self-sufficiency, individualism, and autonomy. Affirming the universality of human needs and the centrality of care in social interactions, scholars have considered the parameters of care both as a set of general, ethical guidelines and in specific circumstances and contexts. With serious limitations, the mainstream in this literature unanimously frames care as unidirectional, intentional, and human-centered. Issuing from the locus of a caring human subject, care is understood, as care ethicists Joan Tronto and Berenice Fisher put it, to be “a species activity that includes everything that we do to maintain, continue, and repair our ‘world’ so that we can live in it as well as possible. That world includes our bodies, our selves, and our environment, all of which we seek to interweave in a complex, life-sustaining web.” Such a vision of care privileges the role of humans, while downplaying the work of infrastructural and non-human actors. In focusing on the personal qualities, attributes, and ethical judgments of the (ideal) caregiver, feminist care ethics privatizes care in responsibilizing individuals and runs the risk of eclipsing structural matters.
Starting with this critique of human-centered feminist care ethics, this thematic panel seeks intersectional case studies that shift the focus from the personal to the infrastructural and look beyond the caring subject to consider objects, infrastructures, and assemblages. How do the above intervene in the construction of a “care web,” using transgender scholar Hil Malatino’s terminology? What theoretical and service-based interventions can we achieve when we conceive of care not (only) as a species activity but as a crafted assemblage? How may we invest in, arrange, and mobilize care infrastructures to devise a sustainable future rather than counting on humans alone?