26. Aged Care Conditions: Solidarity, Resistance, Bargaining

Tamara Daly, Full Professor, York University

This session focuses on care activism, at the level of individuals, coalitions, organizations and government that both illuminate care gaps and hold potential to create better care conditions.

We present findings from our 9-city case study comparing conditions that produce inequitable or inclusive caring conditions alongside those facing precarity and insecurity and needing care, but living with and without it (Toronto, Ottawa, Bergen, Halifax, Copenhagen, Vancouver, Melbourne, Auckland, Taipei). Over 8 years, our project (https://imagine-aging.ca/) has refined a rapid team-based ‘catalytic ethnography’, supported by policy and statistical data analyses to discern the direct and indirect ways in which relational care — care that supports those needing and providing it and pushes against robotic, assembly-line, managerial, overly marketized and commoditized conditions — has been fought for, achieved, and sometimes lost.

This session documents some of those struggles, by communities of carers, within cities, by community organizations, by unions, and on the frontlines as carers who are mostly female, largely migrant, indigenous, and increasingly older carers.

In a world beset by global polycrises and Apps, Algorithms and Artificial Intelligence, good care continues to require hands-on, relational and advocate-oriented problem-solving, even while it is subject to feminized, marketized, colonial and ageist conditions that contribute to its being under-paid and viewed by society as low value.

On reflecting about the good quality Dementia care received by his father, Bill Gates has called for care jobs to be ‘human-reserved’, but as our findings show, this must come with overhauls to the labour process, employment standards, and support for carers. Further, our findings illustrate that activism, resistance, solidarity, shared community, and shared values continue to matter, that cities, communities, coalitions and unions have a significant role to play, and that public opinion, courts, community activism and collective bargaining remain important, even critical, avenues for change.

Papers: Presenting author (*)

  1. Ageing without Care: A Challenge for Care Activism,
    Susan Braedley (*)
  2. Gender Undervaluation, Skills, and Bargaining: Unions and Care Work
    Tamara Daly(*), Sara Charlesworth, and Frode F. Jacobsen
  3. Care Security: Rethinking How Migrants Inhabit the Care Economy,
    Janna Klostermann (*) and Tamara Daly
  4. Moral Economy, Labour Process Theory, and Indigenising Care Work,
    Donna Baines (*), Bindi Bennett, Sean Hillier, Wasiq Silan, Ciwang Teyra, Sheng-Pei Tsai, Frank Wang

Discussants

Martha McDonald and Gudmund Ågotnes

Posted in Symposia.