12. “Autonomy regimes”: new perspective on LTC systems

GIRAUD Olivier, French national center for scientific research (CNRS)

The symposium analyses and compares the systems of support for independent living – referred to as ‘autonomy regimes’ – of five countries (France, Germany, England, Canada and Japan) as they are implemented at various territorial levels and within specific rural and urban areas. Autonomy regimes are defined as the arrangements of service provision supporting autonomy, which stem not only from social discourses, institutionalised norms and concrete measures, but also from the day-to-day practices involved in providing support to older people with reduced autonomy and people with disabilities. The ‘autonomy regimes’approach aims to complement the comparative studies on ‘long-term care regimes’ presented in the international literature, which primarily focus on analysing the provision and regulation of long-term care that enables people with reduced autonomy to carry out the tasks necessary for maintaining their daily lives.

By focusing directly on the notion of autonomy, this new perspective incorporates the aspirations and choices of people with disabilities and older people with reduced autonomy into its analytical framework.

Across the various countries compared, the policy domains involved in supporting individuals’ autonomy – apart from those relating to compensation benefits and care infrastructure – are neither distributed, organised nor coordinated in the same way.

This symposium combines a comparative analysis of the definition of standards of autonomy with an examination of how policies are implemented in a specific area. It examines autonomy frameworks at three distinct levels. The national one is often where the standard for autonomy is defined and the associated rights for those concerned are institutionalised. It is also the level at which policy instruments are designed and strategies for coordinating or integrating the various public policy sectors involved are defined. The regional level, in conjunction with national schemes, resources, existing networks of stakeholders and infrastructure, is primarily concerned with the implementation of schemes, services and instruments. Finally, at the individual level, in conjunction with local resources, the implementation, reception and co-construction of autonomy standards take place alongside and in collaboration with the individuals concerned.

Papers:

Introduction: autonomy regimes as a conceptual approach and as a framework for analysis

  1. Autonomy Regimes as the Coordination of Policy Spaces: Mapping out a Research Agenda beyond Long-Term Care Policies, Olivier Giraud, Lise-CNRS, France, Marie-Victoire Bouquet, Ined, France, Loïc Trabut, Ined, France
  2. From Local Initiatives to Scale: Mobilizing Resources to Support Older Adults with Complex Needs in France and Quebec, Alexandra Charette, Concordia University, Canada, Marie-Victoire Bouquet, National Institute for Demographic Studies, France
  3. Expanding the Boundaries of Care: Agricultural-Welfare Collaboration and the Overflow of Care Policies across Welfare Sectors in Japan, Yukie Shimizu, EHESS, France/Kyoto University, Japan
  4. Frontal collision? Person-centered care meets the reality of long-term care, Patrik Marier, Political Science, Concordia University, Canada, Florian Pisu, National Institute for Demographic Studies, France

Discussants:

BOUQUET Marie-Victoire, French National Institute for Demographic Studies (Ined)

TRABUT Loïc, French National Institute for Demographic Studies (Ined)

Posted in Symposia.