Dr Samantha Clune, Senior Research Fellow La Trobe University, Australia
Workforce shortages in the aged and long-term care systems are a global phenomenon. Key social policy reforms to grow direct care workforce numbers are currently underway in nations like Australia, Spain, the United Kingdom, and the United States, all while in the context of expanding regulatory requirements and consistent demands for high-quality, person-centred care. This symposium examines how public policy, through staffing regulation, wage setting, migration, and employment rights, impacts the quality and stability of care work. Drawing on three empirical studies, we integrate qualitative, quantitative, and mixed-methods evidence from across each of these nations. First, analysis of cross-national policy documents of direct care workforce recruitment, noting consistent themes of targeted migration policy to expedite recruitment. Second, research that examines the limited workforce pools in rural Australia and the capacity of aged care providers to produce tailored initiatives that enhance recruitment and retention endeavours. Third, early findings from England’s Fair Pay Agreement in Adult Social Care and Employment Rights reforms establish baseline workforce conditions and map implementation pathways, risks, and anticipated impacts on job quality and care provision. Finally, a discussant will draw together common themes and identify future directions as evident from each of the research presentation. Together, these papers move beyond documenting workforce crisis to interrogating how regulatory design, collective bargaining, and wage policy operate in practice. The session will advances a comparative policy lens on care work, asking not only how much labour systems require—but how they can be structured to make care work sustainable, equitable, and aligned with the goals of high-quality, person-centred care.
Papers:
- TITLE: Co-Designing Straw: a Strategic Toolbox for Australia’s Rural Aged Care Workforce
Professor Suzanne Hodgkin, Professor of Social Work, Charles Sturt University, Australia
Presenter: Professor Suzanne Hodgkin, Professor Caryn West and Dr Patricia Mackey
Currently around 80 per cent of Australia’s aged care services is delivered in the community sector. A higher proportion of older people live in regional areas than in Australia’s major cities, with one in three older people living in diverse rural and remote communities (34%) yet the availability of services is significantly lower. Those accessing services in rural and remote areas are characterised by dependencies and comorbidities that historically would have qualified them for admission to residential care. There is evidence that groups of rural older people in Australia experience care poverty with delays in accessing community care services due to workforce shortages, problems relating to distance, limited residential care places, and reduced access to broader health care services. This research responds to the increasing need to boost the capacity of the rural community aged care workforce. It reports on a pilot study in a rural coastal township in Australia. Data was collected through expert by experience (EbE) sessions, scoping the extent of workforce shortages, future anticipated demand and current tools and strategies to mitigate against this. Strategies and tools for use by care providers and partners were developed to support and enhance the aged care workforce in rural areas.
- TITLE: Policy reform and workforce precarity in Australia, Spain and the UK aged care sectors
Dr Samantha Clune, Senior Research Fellow La Trobe University, Australia
Presenters: Dr Samantha Clune and Associate Professor Rodrigo Serrat
Sourcing a skilled aged and long-term care workforce is an increasing global challenge. Many OECD countries, such as Australia, Spain, and the UK, have traditionally used various migration pathways as an adjunct to securing a care workforce that is sufficient in numbers and skills to meet local service demand. Globally, aged and long-term care sectors are undergoing significant and broad policy reform, with migration policy clearly under scrutiny. This is in the context of waning international social licence for active recruitment from low to middle income countries given the complexity that that represents to those source countries, and the workers once they arrive. This presentation will showcase findings from an analysis of migration policy for Australia, Spain, and the UK demonstrating how apparent differences in policy directions are coupled with an ongoing, often implied, overall reliance on migration to bolster local care workforces, particularly from low- and middle-income countries. While some policy documents specifically rule out or simply fail to mention targeted migration schemes for workforce recruitment, others have expanded the scope and reach of existing targeted migration schemes. All documents explicitly outline the clear relationship between a skilled, supported care workforce and high-quality care services.
- TITLE: Reconfiguring Pay and Employment Rights in Adult Social Care: Early Evidence from England’s Fair Pay Agreement Reforms
Professor Philip Taylor, Professor, Institute of Employment, University of Warwick, UK
Presenter: Professor Philip Taylor
Adult social care (ASC) in England faces persistent workforce challenges, including low pay, insecure contracts, high turnover, fragmented career pathways, and chronic vacancy pressures. In response, the UK government has introduced sector-level Fair Pay Agreements (FPAs) alongside wider Employment Rights reforms—representing the most significant restructuring of employment regulation in the sector in decades. These reforms aim to improve pay, strengthen employment protections, and enhance recruitment and retention. However, there is limited empirical evidence on how sectoral pay-setting and expanded employment rights will operate within a predominantly outsourced and provider-fragmented care market. This paper presents early findings from a national mixed-methods evaluation of FPAs and Employment Rights reform in ASC. It draws on three strands of analysis: (1) baseline analysis of pay distribution, contract types, job quality indicators, and turnover using national workforce datasets; (2) a structured review of international evidence on sectoral bargaining and care workforce reform; and (3) a stakeholder-informed Theory of Change identifying implementation pathways, mechanisms of impact, and system-level risks. Baseline findings highlight substantial regional and provider-level variation, continued reliance on insecure employment models, and persistent pay gaps relative to comparable occupations. While stakeholders express cautious optimism about the potential to reset employment standards, they also raise concerns regarding funding sufficiency, implementation capacity, compliance burden, and possible unintended consequences for smaller providers. The paper provides timely evidence on the opportunities and constraints associated with collective pay-setting and strengthened employment rights in ASC, and considers whether these reforms can support more sustainable care work, improved workforce stability, and enhanced care quality within a complex mixed-economy system. Implications of these project findings lie in the powerful influence key policy decisions can have on workforce outcomes for what is already a complex and precarious workforce, and how that may influence care outcomes. Findings from this project have implications for global policy development in aged and long-term care.
Discussants:
Professor Caryn West, Professor of Nursing, Charles Sturt University, Australia