5. Producing migrant care worker precarity: Comparative perspectives from Taiwan, Japan and New Zealand

Li-Fang Liang, Department of Sociology, National Dong Hwa University

Shinya Uekusa, Department of Sociology and Anthropology, University of Canterbury

While population aging is generating growing demand for home-based and institutional care globally, care sectors in many developed countries face chronic labor shortages. Migrant care labor has therefore become an important strategy for addressing care deficits, yet migrant care workers’ (MCWs) essential contributions are not necessarily matched by adequate material rewards, social recognition or employment protections. Their precariousness is shaped through the intersection of racial hierarchies, migration regimes, care systems, intermediary agencies, labor markets and the social organization of care work, while the “hidden costs of care” borne by MCWs remain insufficiently recognized and addressed.

This symposium brings together four papers exploring MCW precarity in Taiwan, Japan and New Zealand. Instead of adopting a deficit lens that frames precarity as a common condition of MCW, it adopts a critical comparative approach to explore the social, political, economic and cultural processes that (re)produce precarity across these three countries. Liang and Huỳnh explore how Taiwan’s temporary migration regime intersects with cultural expectations, working conditions and institutional care settings to produce hyperprecarity among Vietnamese MCWs. Cherry investigates the contradictory role of intermediary agencies in Japan’s Technical Intern Training Program, showing how agencies that provide support may also reproduce relations of dependency and control. Khanal explores MCWs’ everyday experiences in New Zealand’s aged care sector, focusing on how precariousness is embedded within global care systems and shaped by linguicism, racism and racialized migration governance. These papers also examine how they negotiate, accommodate and resist structural constraints without obscuring the structural and ideological problems embedded within aged-care systems. Uekusa et al.’s paper calls for a critical approach that theorizes the processes of creating MCW precarity. Based on these findings, the symposium identifies broader policy implications for improving working conditions and human rights protections and addressing the structural conditions that produce and sustain MCW precarity.

Papers (up to 4):

  1. Title: Institutionalizing hyperprecarity: Vietnamese migrant care workers in Taiwanese nursing homes
    Author: Li-Fang Liang, Department of Sociology, National Dong Hwa University
    Author: Huynh Le Anh Huy, Department of Sociology, Ho Chi Minh City Open University/National Dong Hwa University
  2. Title: Migrant Care Workers in Japan: Examining Their Precariousness in Relation to the Role of Intermediary Agencies
    Author: Angela Miku Cherry, Visiting Researcher, Institute for Alternative Systems of Social Welfare and Development, Nihon Fukushi University
  3. Title: Global Care Challenges, Local Realities: Migrant Care Workers in New Zealand
    Author: Diwakar Khanal, Department of Sociology and Anthropology, University of Canterbury
  4. Title: (Re)producing precarity in migrant care work: Towards a critical care and carer studies
    Author: Shinya Uekusa, Department of Sociology and Anthropology, University of Canterbury
    Author: Li-Fang Liang, Department of Sociology, National Dong Hwa University
    Author: Huynh Le Anh Huy, Department of Sociology, Ho Chi Minh City Open University/National Dong Hwa University
    Author: Angela Miku Cherry, Visiting Researcher, Institute for Alternative Systems of Social Welfare and Development, Nihon Fukushi University
    Author: Diwakar Khanal, Department of Sociology and Anthropology, University of Canterbury

Discussant:

Reiko Ogawa, Graduate School of Social Sciences, Chiba University

Posted in Symposia.